Thursday, April 29, 2010


Matt is going through an intense board game phase. He is building an epic collection of Spiel des Jahres winners and player favorites that are now currently taking up residence on our shelf of wonders-our six shelf bookcase that holds all of my toys (Johnny Depp action figures) and his anime DVDs. We stuck a flag in our favorite coffeehouse and have been spending many an afternoon and evening across from one another, strategizing. It’s been a bit of a challenge acquiring the best combination of games that we can play together, however. Being an Action Adventure kind of gamer, I am all for simple moves and rules. Long term strategies are not really my forte. My boyfriend, on the other hand, is wicked brilliant and quite comfortable with board games that come in boxes that weigh as much as our fat cat Mina and include a treasure trove of tiny men, cards, miniature houses, meeple sheep, colorful glass marbles and small bound novels containing the rules. You may be thinking, ‘Like Risk?’ And I would say to you, pshaw, my friend, that’s some Parker Brothers baby talk. So after a lengthy (and ongoing) quest, we have found several games that both of us enjoy together. And since this is a video game blog I thought I would highlight a couple of them that are also available via XBLA.

One of my long-term favorites is a game called Carcassonne. I actually played it for the first time as an Arcade game without even knowing it was also a board game in the physical sense. Playing involves…well, here is what Wiki has to say:

“The game board is a medieval landscape built by the players as the game progresses. The game starts with a single terrain tile face up and 71 others shuffled face down for the players to draw from. On each turn a player draws a new terrain tile and places it adjacent to tiles that are already face up. The new tile must be placed in a way that extends features on the tiles it abuts: roads must connect to roads, fields to fields, and cities to cities. A follower can be placed on the just-placed tile, and must be placed in a specific feature. A follower claims ownership of one terrain feature—road, field, city, or cloister—and may not be placed on a feature already claimed by another player's follower. The game ends when the last tile has been placed [and the game is scored accordingly].”

I really like to play Carcassonne because it’s like an interactive puzzle game. There are many different strategies to win but none that involve serious analysis from move one. As you place the tiles a beautiful pastoral scene with roads and castles emerges, a landscape shaped according to you and your opponent’s decisions (see above picture). I admit, sometimes I place pieces just because I am trying to fill a gap between the tiles. Carcassonne is the kind of game that is best played on a lazy Sunday afternoon or bundled up and taken on vacation. We took it along on our Alaskan cruise last summer and spent a few lovely afternoons in the front facing bar looking over the waters of the Inside Passage while building the French cityscape. One of the great things about playing via the XBLA version is the computer scores the game for you (and adds horse and church bell sound effects while doing so!), which is a blessing as it can get confusing. There are also many expansions for the game that add different rules and flavors to the gameplay.

If given a choice, I would rather play Ticket to Ride over any other game we own. I first played this one via Arcade and liked it, but there is something about the physical board and the tiny trains that is hard to resist. Ticket to Ride is a stealth game. Basically, you are trying to connect two points on a map using matching colored cards to build routes-like the blue route that connects Houston to New York in the screenshot above. But your opponent may be trying to claim a similar route according to what Destination Card they have chosen. So you have to fool them into thinking you may be going somewhere else or they may block your path with their own trains (jerks!)-a fun game of misdirection. I think I like this one because I win a lot. Hey, it’s one of the only ones, so I can glow about it just a little. More than that, however, I just like the Battleship aspect of trying to guess what your opponent is doing based on the clues that emerge during gameplay while still trying to accomplish your own goal. And being in the travel industry (sigh), I also like the maps. Matt thinks I like certain games because of their settings and he is somewhat right when it comes to Ticket to Ride. I also like that it’s another simplistic board game where your only real strategy is to keep a secret as long as you can (and build a train!). We have four different versions: USA, USA 1910, France and Europe. The classic USA version is my favorite, but the European versions add some different kinds of routing and rules to the game.

Over the years I have played a lot of board games turned video games but I would say that these are two of my favorites. Although the Monopoly and Trivial Pursuit video games are quite fun their transition to digital media gave them a lot more animation than necessary, turning them into a garish splash-a-thon of colors and sounds. (I am pretty sure they dumbed Trivial Pursuit down quite a bit as well.) I am glad we are board gamers in addition to video gamers-board games create more social functions. And tabletop gaming is the best way to meet people at gatherings like PAX. I would say that 75% of our friendly gatherings in the last three months or so have involved a board game and a laugh. But I am also glad that the XBLA versions of some of these more obscure games exist. I am currently learning Catan on the Xbox before heading out to play it with some friends in the near future. And because without the Arcade I never would have found Carcassonne in the first place…and then I wouldn’t have impressed my wonderful and nerdy boyfriend by beating him (once!) via Xbox Live, which may or may not be the reason we are dating today. ;)


Abi said...

I love Carcassonne! Maybe we'll play that tomorrow night! I think our boys worked out the game schedule though. ;)

Stefanie said...

Ticket to Ride sounds interesting. We should play one of these next week!

Jessica Dobervich said...

Abi-I think Matt is bringing Carcassonne. It's always a surprise what comes out of the bag when we get to the Wayward.

Stefanie-We will bring both and let you decide. :)